Amazing burgers! Definitely would recommend. No wonder they were awarded best burgers in 2023 and 2024.

This place is the definition of a dive. There is a long line that moves quick, you put in your order and then move aside. There's some tables and fun spinny chairs inside and outside seating. The burgers are super simple, seasoned with salt and pepper, and grilled on the flat top. They don't use any proprietary meats for the burgers so they're really plain; however, that may be the attraction. Highlighting the flavor of the meat by keeping it so simple is definitely a solid move. We ordered two double boss burgers, they were so packed and heavy with sauce and toppings. A really great first bite and you can feel your arteries clogging but it's all good because flavor is everything. The cheese burger was perfectly cooked with nice melty cheese. They have a variety of sauces that are all surprisingly good with the fries. Speaking of fries, don't skimp on the fries. They are some of the best fries I've ever had in my life. They are perfectly crispy, thicker and larger than those other "favorite"fries . For those not into russet potatoes, they have sweet potato tater tots that were very crispy and delicious. Over all, good quality of food, ambiance was perfect for our fireworks display. I would for sure come back again. Between ordering the food and taking my first bite, about 7 minutes, I don't know about you, but that was impressively fast and there was a line out the door. It was a very memorable experience, thanks Burger City - Onto dessert ;)

Burger City has a pretty stellar reputation. This was my first experience here so there was a lot to live up to. Word to the wise, don't order online. Prices listed seem much higher than what is posted on the menus at the site itself. That proved itself out when we ordered for four people (no beverages) and left with a bill that was barely $60. We got there on a Friday sometime after 7PM. It wasn't excessively crowded. There was a line but there is only one person to give an order to so that is to be expected. We had two double quarter pounders, three large fries, a large onion rings, two single burgers and a ten piece chicken nuggets -- this all came to about $60. The "tent" is in a parking lot so there are plenty of spots to park in. We waited maybe 10 minutes for our order. They have minimal seating (at best). Once we got our order home everything was well marked and well packed. They gave us one of each dipping sauce for the nuggets (none were exceptional to be honest) which were very freshly made and tasty. Burgers were cooked to order and the diced onions was a nice unexpected touch. Onion rings tasted battered and the bag is hardly what I would have considered "large" (that's me being picky). The same bag for the fries was very generous. Fries were tasty but definitely benefited from being dipped in ketchup. This was a solid experience. In some ways I might give it a nod above All American Burger further out East in terms of local burger joints. Place is clean and the bagging and packing of the food is very well done also. I will be back.

I placed my pickup order through uber eats and they have a good system for pick up. it reminds me a bit of all american burger. i got the quarter pounder and onion rings. you can choose dipping sauces for free. the prices were fair and the food hit the spot. i want to try the fries next time.

There's nothing not to love about this place. The prices are so cheap and the food is delicious. Real burger lovers know that the good burgers are the greasy smash burgers that this place has. The food came fast (and there were 20 of us on a Friday). Definitely will be back

Voted best burger on Long Island for 2023 and man let me tell you, it definitely is! I've tried burgers all Over Long Island and I have a couple of favs but this has knocked down my list to first place. Basic yet tasty burgers and the ambiance of this place is so cute. I also love the organization of the order/pickup sections. I highly recommend

Have heard about them but didn't get a chance to try them until today. Nice small burger shack with ample parking. Friendly staff and quick service. The quarter pounder with cheese was fantastic. Will be returning.

Been noticing this place lately, as the have signage stating they had won best burger on LI in 2023. Double cheeseburgers was freshly made, hot and tasty and $5. Fries were crispy but not my fast food favorite. Overall, it was pretty good for the price.